Best Subscription Boxes For Multiple Dogs: For 2 Dogs or More (2023 Reviews)

best subscription boxes for multiple dogs

Canine Bible is reader-supported. We receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Learn more.

This is the ultimate guide to finding the best subscription box for multiple dogs.

If you have more than one dog, it can be tough to find a perfect subscription box for all of them. Perhaps you are subscribed to a monthly dog subscription box, but that’s not enough to keep up your five furry friends’ toy and treat demands.

Don’t worry. We’ve got you covered. We have rounded up the best subscription boxes for multiple dogs so that you can buy multiple customizable boxes for all the dogs in your household.

Keep reading to find the best multiple dog subscription box and keep your pack happy! Let’s go!

Top Multiple Dog Subscription Boxes (Our Top Picks At Glance)

Here is a quick overview of just three of our top picks (by category) for the best dog subscription box for multiple dogs. You can click here to go straight to the reviews.

Pet Treater

Best Overall

Read Review


Best Premium

Read Review


Best Affordable

Read Review

What Are Multiple Dog Subscription Boxes?

Companies selling subscription boxes for multiple dogs let you add more than one pet profile to your account.

This feature allows you to customize each box for each dog in your family based on their toy’s needs, size and other preferences.

Buying a subscription box from brands that offer the option to get multiple boxes for multiple dogs can be an excellent way to provide your pets with monthly treats, toys, accessories and other dog products.

Why Get Subscription Boxes For Multiple Dogs?

Giving different dogs a subscription box containing the same products could be the wrong way to pamper and stimulate them.

For instance, small dogs have different needs than large dogs, so you wouldn’t give your tiny chihuahua the same box you bought for your German Shepherd. Toys and treats made for large breeds are not always suitable for smaller dogs, especially toys.

Dog box subscription brands that allow you to order multiple boxes for every dog that you have solved that problem by allowing you to customize the items in each box based on the individual needs of each dog in your household.

Getting a multiple dog subscription box is an excellent idea for many reasons:

  • Multiple pet discounts
  • Personalized items for each dog at home (weight, allergies, heavy chewer, size, age, and others).
  • If you have another pet like a cat, you can add a box
  • Avoid having to place multiple orders
  • Only one account and subscription are required to order for multiple dogs
  • Avoid dogs fighting over toys
  • Have enough treats to give to your dogs
  • It will be fun to see what is in the box

Benefits of Subscription Box For Multiple Dogs

A multiple dog box subscription helps you save money and keep your dogs entertained and happy.

Furthermore, getting more than one subscription box might be necessary to prevent jealousy or annoyance between your furry friends.

A team of researchers headed by Kathryn Wrubel at Tufts University Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine found that the most common reasons that trigger problems between dogs are the owner’s attention to one dog over another, excitement, food and toys. In fact, 46% of the conflicts were caused by food, while 26% of incidents involved were triggered over found items or toys.1

Researchers also believe dogs can form strong emotional attachments to their toys, just like children.2

Providing your dog with its own set of toys and treats (box) can promote a healthier relationship, avoid conflicts and provide emotional support.

A monthly dog box subscription minimizes periods of boredom, keeps toys fresh longer, provides excellent mental stimulation and new challenges for dogs every month.

What to Expect From A Multiple Dog Subscription Box?

Here is what you can expect when you get a dog subscription box for 2 dogs or more.

  • High-quality dog toys
  • Nutritious and all-natural treats
  • Accessories hand-picked by experts
  • Dog items that aren’t always available at the local grocery or pet store
  • A fun experience for your pup when unveiling what’s inside
  • The enjoyment of getting new cool dog stuff every month
  • Many boxes help dogs in need and benefit a cause
  • Discovering new brands and products
  • Support local businesses
  • Great mental stimulation
  • Promotes active play
  • Keep all your dogs happy
  • Never run out of dog toys and treats

Multiple Dog Subscription Box Unboxing

Get a sneak preview of what your dogs can expect from a subscription box by watching these cute dogs unbox it.

Best Monthly Subscription Boxes For Multiple Dogs Reviews

These are the best dog subscription box for multiple dogs.

The main factor we considered in picking the best multiple dog boxes is the brand’s allowed “add multiple pets and boxes” feature. We also considered the level of customization they allowed.

We also based our rankings on customization level, price, customer reviews, toys and treat quality and quantity, and other factors.

Best Overall (Pet Treater)

Pet Treater is our pick for the best box subscription for multiple dogs at home.

This company allows you to add multiple pet profiles, and they will customize your box based on each profile you create. You can even add a cat profile.

pet treater

The subscription box from Pet Treater is available for small, medium and large dogs. Your Pet Treater box includes toys, leashes, poop bags, grooming supplies, outfits, and other accessories. You can cancel anytime if you are not satisfied.

Here are the options Pet Treater offers:

  • Treats-Only Pack ($18/box) – 2 to 5 treats
  • Toys-Only Pack ($18/box) – 2 to 5 hand-selected toys
  • Dog Pack (15/box) – 3-4 toys and treats
  • Deluxe Dog Pack ($25/box) – Box filled with 5-8 hand-selected items, including toys, treats and extra goodies

Their Deluxe box is the best choice if you want the most toys, treats, and accessories per dog (5 to 8 items for $25). But if you only need toys or treats, they offer those boxes too.

  • Caters to allergies
  • Customizable depending on each dog’s needs
  • Toy-only box
  • Treat-only box
  • Easy to navigate website
  • Treats made in the USA or Canada
  • Supports animal shelters
  • Free shipping
  • Is pretty affordable
  • Satisfaction guarantee
  • Cat box available
  • Welcome pack
  • No discounts for multi-month plans

Looking for a Pet Treater coupon code? Use this link to get the best possible deal on Pet Treater.

Best Highest Quality Box For Multiple Dogs (BarkBox)

Can you get a barkbox for 2 dogs? In short, yes.

While BarBox cannot do multi-size boxes, they have an option for every member of your pack. You can get a BarBox for multi-dog households through multiple subscriptions.

BarkBox is the leading monthly dog box brand based on customer reviews and high-quality items in their boxes.

Each box contains five full-sized products, including two innovative toys, two all-natural bags of treats, and one chew centered around a theme. Also, you can add an extra, premium toy to your dog’s BarkBox for just $9 per month.

Their boxes are broken down into three sizes, perfect for families with dogs of all sizes.

  • Small: for pups who are 20 pounds or less
  • Medium: for pups who are 20 to 50 pounds
  • Large: for pups who are over 50 pounds

Their toys are manufactured and designed by them, which you won’t find anywhere else. They don’t outsource toys or treats from other brands.

They offer an extra small box for pups below 9 pounds and you can contact their team for more options. 

  • Allergy-friendly options
  • Excellent price
  • Themed boxes
  • User-friendly website
  • Free shipping for all boxes
  • 10% of proceeds donated to over 3000 rescue organizations
  • Additional surprise gift each birthday
  • Online and text ordering are available
  • Treats made in the USA or Canada
  • Able to change delivery frequency
  • Treats never contain corn, wheat, or soy

    Our readers get exclusive discounts. Just click here to take advantage of the best offer we could find at BarkBox.

    Best Cheapest Subscription For Multiple Dogs (PupJoy)

    PupJoy offers the most affordable price on subscription boxes, and it allows you to add multiple boxes per order.

    Furthermore, you can customize each box with the items you want, which is a nice feature. It will also let you multiple boxes for different dog sizes, making it one of our top favorite picks.

    If you have more than two dogs and want to save some cash, this is your best choice.

    Customers have many box choices, from a Build Your Own option to themed boxes, power chewers boxes and bully boxes. No matter which one you pick, they will delight your pup with curated deliveries of super high-quality artisan treats, toys, & accessories.

    NOTE: The price may vary according to the size of your dogs and whether you have a monthly, 3-month, or 12-month subscription.

    • Customizable
    • Subscription options: 3, 6 and 12-month
    • Products from small USA businesses
    • Durable toys
    • Specify diet restrictions
    • Packaged with eco-friendly shipping materials
    • Excellent customer service
    • Cancel subscription anytime
    • Satisfaction guarantee
    • $2 of your purchase donated to charity

      Our readers get exclusive discounts. Just click here to take advantage of the best offer we could find at PupJoy.

      Best Vet-Approved Dog Box For Multiple Dogs (VetPetBox)

      VetPetBox wins our top pick for the best vet-approved dog subscription box for multiple pets because its contents are hand-selected and evaluated by veterinarians for quality and safety.

      It is also highly customizable, including the following categories: Allergies, chew/playstyle (powerful or responsible), puppy option, anxieties, blindness, and age.

      Their boxes contain 2 toys, 2 healthy treats and the same healthcare items (shampoos, supplements, etc.) that you’d find on the shelf at your vet’s office and other veterinarian-recommended wellness/healthcare products and essential information about dog health.

      The graphic below shows our order of multiple boxes for every dog in our house.

      Prices for VetPetBox start at:

      • 1-month $44.99/box
      • 3-month subscription $40.49/box
      • 6-month subscription $35.99/box

      If you or your dog aren’t satisfied with the box, they will issue a full refund within 30 days.

      • Vet-tested
      • Items are vet-picked
      • Customizable depending on each dog’s needs
      • Caters to allergies
      • Supports animal shelters
      • Free shipping
      • Toys and healthy treats
      • Satisfaction guarantee
      • Cat box available
      • Welcome pack
      • Training and care guide

        Looking for a VetPetBox coupon code? Click here to take advantage of the best offer we could find.

        Best Stylish Box For Multiple Dogs (Dapper Dog Box)

         The Dapper Dog Box is the best stylist box for multiple dogs.

        This box is perfect for fashionable dogs and dog owners who want to be well-stocked with doggy clothing.

        This monthly subscription includes a trendy bandana with every shipment, two treats, and two toys for your pup.

        Dapper Dog offers you the option to customize your box based on each pet’s weight and dietary preferences. Moreover, you can choose whether your dog is a regular or heavy chewer.

        You can order multiple dog subscription boxes with The Dapper Dog.

        As a bonus, parts of the sale of this box go to help shelter dogs

        • Customizable
        • 100% natural treats
        • No wheat, soy, or corn
        • Bandanas are sized
        • Products from small USA businesses
        • Easy to cancel, change, and pause
        • Supports dog shelters
        • Satisfaction guarantee
        • Free shipping

          Looking for a Dapper Dog Box coupon code? Use this link to get the best possible deal on Dapper.

          Best Non-Subscription Boxes For Multiple Dogs (Chewy Goody Box)

          Chewy, the popular online pet retailer, offers over 13 themed dog boxes packed with premium toys, treats and accessories.

          Plus, you can order without a recurring subscription, making it our top pick if you have many dogs at home but want to pamper them only on special occasions without a subscription.

          The items in your Goody Chewy Box are all hand-packed into one fantastic gift box by pet parents who are crazy about their dogs. You can get one box or as many as you please.

          Each box starts at $24.99, making it one of the cheapest and highest quality dog boxes. If you would like to receive this box as a subscription, you can do it through Chewy’s Autoship option at check out and save 30% on your first order. You can cancel at any time.

          • 6 handpicked dog products
          • Pick up just one or as many as you want
          • Great variety
          • Great value
          • You know exactly what’s coming in each box
          • Great for gifts
          • High-quality toys
          • Hand-picked by pet parents for pet parents
          • No subscriptions needed
          • Subscription option available
          • Goody Boxes cannot be customized

          Looking for a Goody Box coupon code? Click here to take advantage of the best offer we could find.

          Best For Cats (Meowbox)

          For dog owners who also have cats at home, there is a box for you too. We added Meowbox as the best subscription box for cats to our list.

          Meowbox is our best cat subscription box because it delivers a wide variety of toys and treats that cats love, offers flexible delivery options, and consistently delivers items on time.

          You can get a Meowbox monthly (5-6 items, $23.95) or every other month (5-6 items, $23.95).

          Their plans are purrfect for one or more cats and come with free shipping. Meowbox toys are designed exclusively by them. If your kitty is a picky eater or has a special diet, try selecting the “No Food” option during checkout to exchange treats for an extra toy.

          You can get a Meowbox and one of our dog boxes picks above if you have a dog and a cat.

          You can pause or skip deliveries on either shipment plan through the user dashboard.

          Looking for a Meowbox coupon code? Use this link to get the best possible deal on Meowbox.

          Best Subscription Boxes Compared

          Are you wondering how Pet Treater vs. BarkBox and the other stack up? This comparison table breaks down the differences.

          CharacteristicsPet Treater Dog BoxBarkBoxPupJoyVetPetBoxDapper Dog BoxChewy Goody BoxMeowbox
          What's In The BoxDog Pack (3-4 items); Deluxe Dog Pack (5-8 items)2 Treats, 2 Toys, & 1 Chew2 Treats, 1 Toys, & 2 Chews2 toys, 2 healthy treats healthcare items2 Treats, 2 Toys, & 1 Stylish Bandana1 Leash, 1 Poop Bag, 1 Shampoo, 2 Toys & 1 Treat5-6 items
          Delivery Time10th of Each MonthShips Immediately48 Hours or Sooner1 to 3 DaysShips Within 3-7 Business Days1 to 3 Days
          Free ShippingYesYesYesYesYesFree Shipping on Orders of $49 or MoreYes
          1 Month Subscription$25$35$24.99$44.99$35.99$24.99$23.95
          3 Month Subscription$25$23.74$40.49
          6 Month Subscription$25$26$22.49$35.99$32.99
          12 Month Subscription$25$23$21.24$30.00
          Lite Option$15
          Satisfaction GuaranteeReplaces Toys If Pup Doesn't Like ThemFull Refund Within 30 DaysReplace ItemsFull Refund Within 30 Days
          Extra Toy Cost$9
          Customization OptionsYesYesYes
          Caters To AllergiesYesYesYesYesYes
          Themed BoxesYesYesYes
          Change Delivery FrequencyYesYesYesYesYes
          One-Time Option (Puppy Gift Box)YesYesYesYesYesYesYes
          Heavy Chewer Puppy OptionYesYesYesYesYes

          Are Multiple Dog Subscription Boxes Worth It? Alternatives

          There are many different types of dog subscription boxes to choose from. Some people may find it worth the money to have one box shipped to them every month for all their dogs, while others may think it’s best to buy a box for every dog in the home.

          We recommend dogs get their toys and treat to avoid conflict among them and keep everyone happy when possible.

          If you have a puppy, heavy chewer, or want to save money on dog subscription boxes, read our monthly puppy boxes, cheap subscription boxes, or heavy chewer boxes articles.

          Like It? Subscribe & Share!

          * indicates required

          Sources and References: [1] Victoria Advocate; [2] Bris [3] Express UK

          Similar Posts