The 15 Best Peanut Butters for Dogs 2025: Vet-Approved

This content was reviewed and fact-checked by veterinarian Dr. Sandra Tashkovska, DVM.

Peanut butter is more than just a tasty treat for dogs—it can be a high-reward training tool, a fun puzzle toy filler, or even a soothing aid for anxiety. But not all peanut butters are safe or healthy for our canine companions. Some contain harmful ingredients like xylitol, excess salt, or added sugars that can pose serious health risks. In this guide, we’ve done the digging to help you find the best peanut butter for dogs across a variety of needs—from calming formulas with CBD to low-fat options for weight management. Whether you’re looking for a creamy everyday spread, a chunky treat for enrichment, or a natural peanut butter that’s free from additives, we’ve got a tail-wagging recommendation for every pup.

What to Look for In Peanut Butter for Dogs

Benefits

Here are the benefits of peanut butter for dogs:

• 🧼 Distraction Aid – Helpful during grooming, nail trims, or vet visits
• 🐾 High in Protein – Supports muscle maintenance and energy levels
• 🧠 Contains Healthy Fats – Promotes skin health and a shiny coat
• 🦴 Rich in Vitamins B & E – Boosts immune health and cell function
• ❤️ Good Source of Niacin – Helps with metabolism and circulation
• 🐶 Great for Training – Works as a high-value reward for positive reinforcement
• 🧩 Perfect for Enrichment Toys – Keeps dogs mentally stimulated (e.g., stuffed in KONGs)
• 😌 Can Help with Anxiety – Used with calming ingredients like CBD to soothe nervous dogs
• 🐕 Tasty and Appealing – Encourages picky eaters to take meds or supplements

Curious about the science behind peanut butter and dogs? Read our in-depth guide: Can Dogs Eat Peanut Butter? to learn what’s safe, what’s not, and why.

Always consult your veterinarian before changing your dog’s diet. You can get personalized nutritional advice from an online registered vet nutritionist through Vetster anytime, anywhere. You can also chat with an online vet to ask specific questions about safe peanut butter ingredients and how it fits into your dog’s nutritional needs. To further tailor your dog’s diet, consider using an at-home dog gut health test to analyze their microbiome, which can help determine which nutrients support optimal digestion. Likewise, a dog allergy testing kit can help identify potential sensitivities to ingredients commonly found in peanut butter, such as peanuts or added oils. These tools can help you make informed decisions and ensure you’re choosing the safest, healthiest peanut butter for your dog.

Best Peanut Butters For Dogs

Here are the best peanut butters for dogs this year.

Best Overall Peanut Butter for Dogs

Main ingredient: Peanuts

Other ingr: Honey

Volume: 17-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: BUDDY BUDDER Ruff Ruff Raw formula (just unsalted peanuts and a touch of honey) ensures not only safety but also digestibility for dogs with sensitive stomachs. The peanut butter can be refrigerated for a thicker texture, making it easier to use as a pill pocket or to stuff enrichment toys. Some users note the natural separation of oils as a minor inconvenience, but see this as a sign of its truly unprocessed nature

What sets it apart from competitors: The formulation doesn’t just avoid harmful extras—it’s also multipurpose. Owners frequently use this peanut butter as a lickable treat, an ingredient in homemade dog snacks, or as a practical distraction aid. Its adaptability and focus on clean ingredients set it a notch above most alternatives.

Best Human-Grade Peanut Butter for Dogs

Main ingredient: Peanuts

Other ingr: Honey

Volume: 12-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: Nashville, USA

Why we recommended it: Zoomie Butter is crafted in small batches in Nashville using human‑grade peanuts and honey, without added salt, stabilizers, palm oil, xylitol, or artificial sugars. That transparency is rare. Reviewers note it “smells no different than regular peanut butter” and has a “good consistency” — dogs seem to agree, with comments like “My doggo has no complaints” One even joked it gave their pup “too much zoomies”—a playful sign of excited energy!

What sets it apart from competitors: Zoomie Butter is specifically labeled for dogs, reassuring you that no artificial sweeteners (especially xylitol) have slipped in—so it avoids a major risk. It’s also made in the USA in small, quality‑focused batches, offering that human‑grade peace of mind, yet still dog‑approved.

Best Calming Peanut Butter for Dogs

Main ingredient: Peanuts

Other ingr: Hemp oil/CBD

Volume: 15-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: Honest Paws Calm CBD Peanut Butter delivers consistent full-spectrum hemp extract—about 5 mg CBD per tablespoon from a total of 160 mg in a 15 oz jar. The USDA‑organic hemp is U.S.-grown, third-party lab-tested, and NASC-certified, ensuring quality and safety. Owners regularly report calmer behavior during stress triggers—car rides, separation anxiety, or fireworks—with pets happily gobbling it up (“safe and effective for your dog”). It’s simple to spread on toys or mix it into meals, transforming stressful events like thunderstorms or vet visits into more manageable experiences.

What sets it apart from competitors: Steadfast commitment to clean, organic, and functional ingredients. It refrains from adding artificial flavors, GMOs, soy, or corn. Rigorous third-party testing backs its purity and potency claims, offering extra peace of mind. Another distinguishing feature is the product’s NASC certification, which signals higher standards in labeling and manufacturing practices.

Best Peanut Butter for Dogs With Sensisitve Stomachs

Main ingredient: Peanuts

Other ingr: None

Volume: 16-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: Spread The Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter contains only one ingredient: USDA‑certified organic peanuts—nothing more. That means no palm oil, salt, sugar, or artificial stabilizers—each jar is simply dry‑roasted peanuts. This straightforward formula keeps the pH balance gentle (around neutral), avoiding ingredients that can flare gut sensitivity. Its small‑batch production in California—and multiple Clean Choice Awards—underline its quality.

What sets it apart from competitors: Human‑grade and certified organic and kosher, gluten‑free, vegan, non‑GMO, with no hidden extras. The brand is also woman-owned and consistently avoids palm oil—values that resonate with conscientious buyers who are interested in ethical and healthy choices for their pets.

Best Peanut Butter for Dogs With Superfoods (Immune Support)

Main ingredient: Peanuts

Other ingr: CBD, turmeric flaxseed oil & hemp oil

Volume: 16-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: The Nutty Hemp fuses full-spectrum hemp CBD (USDA Oregon–sourced, with only 0.01% THC) and nutrient-dense hemp seed oil—rich in omega-3s, omega-6s, gamma-linolenic acid, and vitamins A & B—which helps boost immune function and enhance CBD absorption. It also includes turmeric and flaxseed oil for added antioxidant and anti-inflammatory benefits. With third-party lab testing and non-GMO ingredients, you’re getting a reliable and transparent formula. Owners often note improvements in energy, mobility, and stress levels, especially for older dogs or those dealing with joint discomfort. It’s a strong choice for senior dogs, active breeds, or those prone to stress and inflammation.

What sets it apart from competitors: This blend provides immune and joint support, not just calming benefits. The full-spectrum extract delivers a broader cannabinoid profile (including boosted CBD, CBG, CBC), offering more than products with isolate or narrow-spectrum blends

Best Chunky Peanut Butter for Dogs

Main ingredient: Peanuts

Other ingr: Pinch of salt

Volume: 16-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: Teddie Super Chunky keeps things simple: just dry-roasted peanuts and a pinch of salt, non-GMO, gluten-free, kosher, and vegan—all in a USA-made, human-grade product. The oil separation is natural, so you just stir and you’re good to go—no hydrogenated oils, palm oil, or artificial additives. That means balanced pH and healthy unsaturated fats, delivering niacin, fiber, and protein suitable for enrichment or nutritional treats. Its consistency offers a satisfying crunch that dogs find stimulating and enjoyable, making it perfect for stuffing toys, licking treats, or using as a training reward.

What sets it apart from competitors: It’s especially suitable for medium to large breeds that can handle the bits, but may be less ideal for very small or flat-faced breeds due to potential choking hazards

Best Peanut Butter Ice Cream for Dogs

Main ingredient: Lactose‑free milk

Other ingr: Peanuts, cane sugar, gelatin, a bit of salt

Volume: 5.25-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: Pooch Creamery Peanut Butter Flavor Ice Cream Mix for Dogs uses all-natural, lactose-free whole milk as the base with added peanuts for flavor, carefully balanced to avoid the high sugar and fat content commonly found in human ice cream that can cause digestive upset or pancreatitis in dogs. Its powdered form means it stores well at room temperature and is simple to make by just adding water and freezing, which allows owners to customize serving size and frequency. Many owners praise its creamy texture and dogs’ enthusiastic response to the peanut butter flavor. Veterinarian Jennifer Sperry, DVM, specifically highlights it as the best choice among dog ice creams for its limited ingredient list and safety profile.

What sets it apart from competitors: The calorie content is controlled (~16 kcal per 1 oz scoop for peanut butter flavor), supporting weight management when used as an occasional treat. This combination of safety, ease of use, and thoughtful nutrition distinguishes it in the growing market of dog-friendly ice cream mixes.

Best Peanut Butter Powder for Dogs

Main ingredient: Peanut powder

Other ingr: None

Volume: 24-ounce jar

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: NAKED Organic Powdered Peanut Butter is made with just one ingredient—slow-roasted, non‑GMO U.S. peanuts—this product delivers authentic taste with about 75% fewer calories and over 85% less fat than traditional peanut butter Spread The Love Foods+15Naked Nutrition+15Walmart.com+15. It’s mechanically pressed without hexane, third-party tested for heavy metals, and gluten‑, soy‑, dairy‑free—an excellent choice for dogs with dietary sensitivities or those needing leaner snacks.

What sets it apart from competitors: This formula also blends seamlessly with water or yogurt to form spreads or toppings, without the oily mess of jarred butter. Plus, it’s USDA‑organic certified in the “Organic” variety and sourced directly from U.S. farms

Best Peanut Butter Pill Pockets for Dogs

Main ingredient: Peanuts

Other ingr: Glycerin, wheat flour & more

Volume: 15.8-ounce bag

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: Greenies Pill Pockets are the #1 veterinarian‑recommended pill‑hiding treat in the U.S.—not just by marketing claims but based on vet surveys. They’re crafted with real peanut butter as the first ingredient, supported by a soft, moldable dough of glycerin, wheat flour, and vegetable oil, making them easy to use and digest. Owners consistently report that these treats turn stressful med routines into something dogs eagerly look forward to: “game changer,” “works every time,” and “dog thinks it’s a treat” are common praises

What sets it apart from competitors: Beyond taste, what really distinguishes Greenies is its shapeable pouch design that hides pills effectively. Unlike improvising with peanut butter or cheese, these treats are formulated to seal around the medication, minimizing mess and fuss. While homemade methods vary, Greenies offers a reliable texture and flavor repeatedly praised in reviews. The large size fits most capsules, and feeding guidelines (1 treat per 15 lb) help ensure appropriate dosing.

Best Peanut Butter Treat for Dogs

Main ingredient: Peanuts and goat’s milk

Other ingr: Barley, rolled oats, tapioca, honey & more

Volume: 8-ounce bag

Age range: All ages

Made in: USA

Why we recommended it: The Honest Kitchen Goat’s Milk N’ Cookies: Slow Baked with Peanut Butter & Honey combines probiotic benefits from real goat’s milk with nutrient-dense ingredients such as peanut butter, rolled oats, and honey—slow baked to preserve digestive support and flavor. The inclusion of bacillus coagulans, a probiotic strain, promotes gut health, which is a key factor for dogs prone to digestive upset. The slow baking process yields a crunchy yet not overly hard cookie that dogs find enjoyable without being damaging to teeth.

What sets it apart from competitors: Dual focus on digestive health and flavor appeal in a treat that uses human-grade, natural ingredients without artificial preservatives or additives. 

Other Peanut Butter for Dogs

The Bottom Line

Choosing the best peanut butter for your dog comes down to more than just taste. The right option should be free from harmful additives, align with your pup’s dietary needs, and fit their lifestyle—whether they’re a growing puppy, a senior with a sensitive stomach, or a high-energy dog in need of protein-packed snacks. From calming peanut butters infused with CBD to budget-friendly everyday staples, there’s a perfect match for every dog (and every budget). Just remember to always check the ingredient label and avoid dangerous sweeteners like xylitol. At the end of the day, peanut butter can be a safe, healthy, and tail-waggingly rewarding treat—when you pick the right one.

Like It? Subscribe & Share!

* indicates required

First Name *

Email Address *

Dog Breed

Leave this field empty if you’re human:

Sources

Canine Bible uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process and product review methodology to learn more about how we fact-check, test products, and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.