Imagine spending every day in the same room, staring at the same objects, with nothing to challenge your mind or body. Sounds unbearable, right? Yet, for many dogs, that’s exactly what life is like without the right toys. A staggering 80% of behavioral issues in dogs stem from boredom and lack of stimulation—chewed-up shoes, relentless barking, and even anxiety. You probably already have a basket full of toys, but here’s the kicker: most aren’t doing what they’re supposed to. Some are too easy, some too boring, and others can even be dangerous. So, how do you choose a toy that truly engages your pup—keeping them mentally sharp, physically active, and emotionally fulfilled? This guide reveals the best dog toys for every play need.
How to Pick the Best Dog Toys
Choosing the right toy for your dog is essential for their safety, engagement, and overall well-being. Here are the key factors to consider when selecting the best dog toys:
1. Consider your dog’s size and breed: Large breeds like Labradors and German Shepherds need sturdy, oversized toys that won’t pose a choking hazard, while smaller breeds like Chihuahuas or Dachshunds require appropriately sized toys that are easy to carry and chew.
2. Match the toy to your dog’s play style: Every dog has a different play style, so choosing toys that align with their preferences ensures they stay engaged.
Chewers: Durable rubber or nylon chew toys help satisfy dogs that love to gnaw.
Fetch lovers: Balls, frisbees, or retrieving dummies work great for high-energy dogs that enjoy chasing and retrieving.
Tuggers: Rope toys or strong rubber tug toys are ideal for dogs that enjoy interactive play with their owners.
Problem solvers: Puzzle or treat-dispensing toys keep intelligent breeds like Border Collies and Poodles mentally stimulated.
3. Safety comes first: Dog toys should be free of small, breakable parts that can be swallowed or become choking hazards. Avoid toys with cheap stuffing, toxic dyes, or weak seams that can easily rip apart. Opt for non-toxic, BPA-free materials that are safe for chewing.
4. Choose the right material for durability
Rubber: Ideal for aggressive chewers; strong yet flexible enough to be safe on teeth.
Rope: Great for tug-of-war and chewing but should be monitored to prevent fraying.
Plush: Best for gentle chewers or comfort-seeking dogs but not ideal for destructive chewers.
Nylon: Long-lasting and designed for powerful chewers, often infused with flavors for added interest.
5. Look for toys that promote mental and physical stimulation: Dogs thrive on engagement, so picking interactive dog toys that challenge them physically and mentally helps prevent boredom.
6. Monitor playtime: Before allowing your dog to play unsupervised, observe how it interacts with a new toy. If it quickly destroys it or shows signs of chewing off small pieces, remove the toy to prevent any choking or digestive issues.
Best Dog Toys
We tested the most popular dog toys to find out which ones truly stand out. From the best overall to top picks for puppies, tough chewers, and interactive play, our hands-on reviews reveal the toys that deliver durability, engagement, and tail-wagging fun. Here’s what we found!
Best Overall Dog Toy
4.8
★★★★★
KONG Classic
Who It’s For: The most well-rounded dog toy on the market. An excellent option for pet owners looking for a versatile, durable, fun, and mentally stimulating toy.
Why we recommended it:The KONG Classic offers unmatched durability and versatility. The natural rubber material is tough enough to withstand aggressive chewers while remaining gentle on teeth and gums. It is a “three-in-one” solution: a chew toy, fetch companion, and treat dispenser. Its hollow, stuffable design keeps dogs engaged for extended periods, whether filled with peanut butter, kibble, or frozen mixtures, keeping dogs engaged for extended periods and provides mental stimulation. Its 40-year proven track record speaks volumes about user satisfaction.
What sets it apart from competitors: KONG Classic’s signature snowman shape creates an unpredictable bounce, making fetch games more engaging than standard balls. Unlike many toys, it’s crafted from FDA-approved, non-toxic natural rubber free from BPA and phthalates, ensuring safety even for dogs with sensitive stomachs. It’s also dishwasher-safe, making cleanup easy after messy treat-stuffing sessions—something many pet owners appreciate.
Why we recommended it:BarkBox BarkBox delivers a curated mix of excitement and practicality. Each box includes 2-4 toys, 2 treat bags, and a chew and is thoughtfully curated based on your dog’s size and preferences, making it a one-stop shop for mental stimulation and play. You can even upgrade to their Extra Toy Club and get an additional premium toy in every box for only $9/month. You can also find individual BarkBox toys on Amazon, but we recommend their boxes for saving and more exclusive toys.
What sets it apart from competitors: BarkBox’s themed boxes (e.g., Marvel, holiday specials) and exclusive collaborations create a sense of novelty that rivals lack. They even have a Super Chewer option, offering more durable toys that stand up to aggressive chewing—a feature many competitors lack.
Best Interactive Dog Toy
4.6
★★★★★
Outward Hound
Who It’s For: Perfect for dogs that enjoy problem-solving and interactive play.
Why we recommended it: The Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Puzzle Toy is designed to challenge a dog’s mind while tapping into their natural hunting instincts. It combines playtime with cognitive stimulation. The soft tree trunk contains multiple squeaky plush squirrels that dogs must sniff out and pull free, mimicking the excitement of foraging. This keeps dogs entertained for extended periods and helps curb unwanted behaviors caused by boredom.
What sets it apart from competitors: Replacement squirrels are available, extending the toy’s lifespan and reducing waste—a win for budget-conscious pet parents. While it’s not indestructible, many users report the squirrels surprisingly outlast the trunk, with some lasting over a year. Outward Hound also offers themed alternatives (Hide-A-Bee, Hedgehog, etc.), letting owners rotate designs to keep dogs intrigued.
Why we recommended it: The Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Dog Worker Puzzle Toy (Level 3 Advanced) transforms treat time into a multi-step brain game. It goes beyond simple treat dispensers by requiring dogs to perform multiple actions such as swivel flippers, scoot blocks, and spin a wheel to uncover hidden rewards. Designed with sliding, spinning, and flipping components, it forces dogs to think critically and experiment with different movements to uncover hidden treats. It’s also made from a durable, food-safe composite material that resists wearing better than basic plastic models, while rubber feet prevent sliding on hard floors.
What sets it apart from competitors: The Dog Worker demands sequential problem-solving, mimicking real-world challenges that engage a dog’s cognitive muscles. Its non-removable parts eliminate choking risks, providing a safety edge over toys with detachable pieces.
Best Dog Toy for Puppies
4.5
★★★★★
KIPRITII Puppy Chew Toys 14-Pack
Who It’s For: Puppy owners looking to provide a variety of safe, engaging toys to help with teething, chewing, and playtime.
Why we recommended it:The KIPRITII Puppy Chew Toys 14-Pack is ideal for breeds going through the teething phase, helping to soothe sore gums while preventing destructive chewing on furniture, shoes, and other household items. We recommend this set because it offers an affordable, all-in-one solution for keeping puppies entertained and mentally stimulated. The variety of textures and toy types—including rope toys, rubber chew toys, and plush squeaky toys—ensures there’s something for every type of play.
What sets it apart from competitors: While many puppy chew toys are sold individually, its sheer variety at an affordable price point makes this the best choice for puppy owners. The inclusion of poop bags and a storage basket adds practical value for busy pet parents.
Best Dog Toy for Chewers
4.7
★★★★★
Benebone Wishbone
Who It’s For: Designed for dogs that instinctively love to chew. Excellent for dogs who need a long-lasting and engaging chew toy.
Why we recommended it:The Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone’s shape delivers three key wins: durability, flavor, and dental benefits. Unlike rawhide or softer chew toys that break down quickly, Benebone is made from tough nylon infused with real flavors like bacon, chicken, or peanut butter. Many dog owners praise its longevity and how it keeps their pets engaged for hours without crumbling or making a mess.
What sets it apart from competitors: The curved wishbone shape mimics natural chewing angles, allowing dogs to hold it comfortably with their paws for more controlled chewing. This reduces boredom and redirects destructive habits away from furniture.
Best Indestructible Dog Toy (Most Durable Dog Toy For Heavy Chewers)
4.7
★★★★★
Waiting to play
Super Chewer Box
Who It’s For: Designed for dogs that destroy typical toys within minutes. These toys are made from the most durable materials.
Why we recommended it:The Super Chewer Box combines durability with entertainment, offering toys made from heavy-duty rubber and nylon that withstand relentless chewing. If your pup is a power chewer—whether it’s a Pit Bull, Rottweiler, or a large-breed dog with an unstoppable jaw—this subscription box delivers ultra-durable toys built to last. It’s ideal for pet parents who want a steady supply of tough, engaging chew toys that stand up to aggressive chewing. Each box includes two to three tough chew toys, two bags of all-natural human-grade treats, and two meaty chews, ensuring that dogs stay entertained and rewarded, making it a well-rounded enrichment experience.
What sets it apart from competitors: Unlike generic tough-chew toys sold individually, this box offers a rotating themed selection of new, engaging designs each month. If a toy doesn’t hold up, BarkBox will replace it for free—something many dog owners appreciate when dealing with relentless chewers. You can also find individual Super Chewer toys on Amazon, but we recommend their boxes for saving and more exclusive indestructible toys.
Why we recommended it:The Eefitoys Heavy Duty Dog Rope Toys have an extra-thick, durable rope construction that holds up well to strong pulling and chewing. Unlike standard rope toys that fray quickly, this one is made from tightly woven, heavy-duty cotton fibers that resist wear and tear. Made with OEKO-TEX-certified materials, the ropes are free from harmful chemicals like BPA, phthalates, and heavy metals, ensuring they’re safe for prolonged chewing. The set’s machine-washable feature stands out, addressing the “stinky rope” issue common with other brands
What sets it apart from competitors: The multi-functional design (tug, fetch, chew) and inclusion of thick, double-knotted ropes cater to all dogs including power chewers, while cheaper alternatives fray within days.
Best Dog Toy for Fetch
4.6
★★★★★
Chuckit! Classic Ball Launcher
Who It’s For: Perfect for dogs that love to chase and retrieve, especially high-energy breeds. Excellent for enhancing a dog’s exercise routine while reducing strain on the arms.
Why we recommended it:The Chuckit! Classic Ball Launcher transforms fetch into a low-effort, high-reward game for both dogs and humans. Owners praise its ability to throw balls 2–3 times farther than manual throws, giving dogs a more rigorous workout in less time. The ergonomic handle reduces shoulder strain, and the “slobber-free pickup” claw lets you avoid soggy, dirt-caked balls—a godsend for germ-conscious pet parents. It’s also versatile: works with standard tennis balls or Chuckit!-brand balls (like the Ultra Ball), which float for water play and glow for nighttime visibility.
What sets it apart from competitors: Unlike basic throwers, its curved plastic claw securely grips balls mid-fetch, eliminating the need to bend or touch saliva-covered toys—a feature competitors like generic launchers lack
Best Plush Dog Toy
4.5
★★★★★
Best Pet Supplies
Who It’s For: Ideal for dogs who enjoy soft, cuddly toys but tend to shred stuffed plush toys.
Why we recommended it: The Best Pet Supplies Chicken Crinkle Plush Dog strikes a balance between softness and interactive play. The realistic animal shapes and multiple squeakers keep dogs engaged, whether they’re playing solo or with their owner. Many pet parents praise it for being a favorite snuggle buddy for their dogs and a fun, low-impact play option for older dogs or those with sensitive teeth. Aside from the chicken toy, there are many other animals to choose from.
What sets it apart from competitors: Its stuffing-free design eliminates the risk of stuffing spills while still being soft and fun to play with.
Best Automatic Dog Toy (Self-moving)
4.5
★★★★★
Cheerble
Who It’s For: Perfect for pet owners looking to keep their dogs entertained even when they’re not around
Why we recommended it:Cheerble’s Wicked Ball transforms playtime into a tech-driven adventure with minimal human effort. It keeps dogs “entertained for hours” through self-activated rolling, bouncing, and flashing lights, which trigger natural hunting instincts. The three customizable modes (Gentle, Normal, Active) adapt to your dog’s energy level—ideal for calming hyperactive pups or engaging lazy ones. It’s rechargeable via USB, eliminating the need for disposable batteries.
What sets it apart from competitors: With built-in motion sensors, the ball reacts to a dog’s touch, rolling, bouncing, and changing directions on its own. Unlike traditional fetch toys, it doesn’t require an owner’s involvement, making it a great option for solo play. It also keeps dogs intrigued and active even when you are away.
Best Calming Dog Toy (for Anxious Dogs)
4.5
★★★★★
Original Snuggle Puppy
Who It’s For: Great for puppies adjusting to new homes, dogs with separation anxiety, or pets stressed by loud noises (e.g., thunderstorms, fireworks).
Why we recommended it: The SmartPetLove Original Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Stuffed Dog Toy is especially beneficial for puppies leaving their litter for the first time or dogs adapting to a new environment. If your dog experiences stress during thunderstorms, travel, or being left alone, this plush toy provides a comforting, realistic alternative to human companionship. —many report dogs snuggling silently in their crates or falling asleep faster, even during stressful events like vet visits. The included disposable heat pack also provides additional warmth, enhancing the calming effect.
What sets it apart from competitors: It mimics the warmth and heartbeat of a mother, offering a soothing presence that helps reduce anxiety. The heartbeat mechanism creates a gentle pulsing sensation, mimicking the feeling of cuddling with a littermate or mother.
Best Ball Dog Toy
4.5
★★★★★
Hartz DuraPlay
Who It’s For: Perfect for dogs that love playing with balls but also enjoy fetching and chewing on their toys between play sessions.
Why we recommended it:The Hartz DuraPlay Ball toy combines sensory appeal with practicality. The irresistible bacon scent keeps dogs engaged, while the natural latex exterior and foam interior create a chewy, bouncy texture that’s gentle on gums. Its lightweight design allows easy throwing, and its easy-to-clean surface holds well in mud or water. The built-in squeaker adds auditory stimulation, making it a hit for dogs who love noise-making toys.
What sets it apart from competitors: Unlike standard fetch toys, it floats in water, doubling as a pool or lake companion—a rarity in scented toys. Its foam-filled latex construction creates an unpredictable bounce while maintaining a softer feel than traditional rubber balls.
Best Water Dog Toy
4.5
★★★★★
Chuckit! Amphibious Bumper
Who It’s For: Perfect for water-loving dogs that enjoy retrieving toys from lakes, pools, or the beach.
Why we recommended it:The Chuckit! Amphibious Bumper excels in water visibility and buoyancy, floating high on the surface to keep dogs engaged without sinking—even during vigorous play. It’s gentle on mouths while resisting abrasion from water and rough play. The knotted rope handle provides a non-slip grip for tug-of-war or launching, and its bright colors make it easy to spot in murky water. It’s easy to clean, adding practicality for messy outdoor adventures.
What sets it apart from competitors: While some water toys absorb water and become heavy, this one remains buoyant and quick-drying. The rope handle makes it easy to toss far distances without excessive effort, which is a big plus for dog owners who want to extend their dog’s swimming workouts.
Best Squeaky Dog Toy
4.5
★★★★★
FIREOR Dog Squeak Toys
Who It’s For: ideal for dogs that enjoy chasing, chewing, and engaging with squeaky sounds.
Why we recommended it:The FIREOR Dog Squeak Toy combines durability with engaging sound effects, keeping dogs entertained for extended play sessions. The dual built-in squeaker is loud enough to capture a dog’s attention without being overly disruptive for owners.
What sets it apart from competitors: Unlike many plush squeaky toys that fall apart quickly, this toy is built with a reinforced design and chew-resistant materials that help it last longer, even with frequent chewing.
Other Best Dog Toys
Best Dog Toy for Chase: Interactive Flirt Pole Toy is the ultimate chase toy for high-energy dogs that love to sprint and pounce. It mimics the movement of prey, keeping dogs mentally and physically engaged while strengthening their natural instincts. This toy is perfect for training, exercising, and burning off excess energy, making it a great option for working breeds and active pups. The sturdy pole and durable rope ensure long-lasting fun, even for enthusiastic chasers. Owners appreciate how easy it is to use and how quickly it tires out their dogs, providing a great workout with minimal effort. This flirt pole is a must-have if you have a dog that loves to chase.
Best Disc Dog Toy: The KONG Flyer is a top-tier flying disc designed for dogs who love to fetch. Made from KONG’s signature natural rubber, it offers durability while remaining soft on dogs’ teeth and gums. Unlike hard plastic frisbees that can crack or cause dental injuries, this disc has a flexible, safe design that makes catching comfortable for dogs. It flies smoothly and accurately, making it ideal for outdoor play in parks or backyards. Many dog owners love how this frisbee holds up against repeated use without losing shape. Whether your dog is a casual fetcher or a disc sports enthusiast, the KONG Flyer is the best choice.
Best Dog Toy for Large Dogs: TheKseroo Chew Toy is specifically designed for large dogs with powerful jaws, making it an excellent choice for aggressive chewers. Made from tough, non-toxic natural rubber, it withstands heavy chewing while promoting healthy gums and teeth. The textured surface and ridges help clean teeth, reducing plaque and tartar buildup. It also doubles as a boredom-buster, keeping dogs entertained for long periods while preventing destructive chewing. Dog owners rave about its durability, especially for breeds like German Shepherds, Pit Bulls, and Rottweilers. This toy is a solid investment if you have a large dog that loves to chew.
Best Budget Dog Toy: Multipet Gumby Dog Plush Toy is an affordable yet fun option for dogs who love plush toys. Inspired by the nostalgic Gumby character, it has a soft, cuddly design that dogs enjoy snuggling with. Despite its budget-friendly price, it offers decent durability for light to moderate chewers. It also includes a squeaker to keep dogs engaged and entertained during playtime. Owners appreciate how it provides both comfort and fun at an accessible price point. This plush toy is great if you’re looking for an inexpensive but enjoyable toy for your pup.
Best Puzzle Dog Toy: Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Dog Brick Dog Puzzle is the best choice for dogs that love mental stimulation. Designed with sliding and flipping compartments, it challenges dogs to find hidden treats, keeping them engaged and entertained. This interactive toy helps reduce boredom, prevent destructive behaviors, and strengthen problem-solving skills. It’s also an excellent option for dogs needing extra indoor stimulation, especially during rainy days. Dog owners love how it provides a fun and rewarding challenge while slowing down fast eaters. If your dog enjoys brain games, this puzzle toy is a fantastic investment.
Best Silent Dog Toy: ZippyPaws Snooziez with Squeaker is the perfect toy for dogs who love squeaky toys—but with a twist: the squeaker is silent to humans. While it produces an engaging sound only dogs can hear, it eliminates the noise that might annoy owners. The soft plush design makes it great for cuddling, while the silent squeaker keeps dogs entertained without disturbing the household. This is especially ideal for nighttime play or apartment living where noise levels need to be minimal. Owners love how it keeps their dogs engaged while maintaining a peaceful environment. This is a great pick if you want a quiet but stimulating toy.
Best Dog Toy for Small Dogs: 9 Pack Small Dogs Puppy Squeaky Dog SZKOKUHO is perfect for small dogs and puppies who love a variety of toys. Each toy is designed with a squeaker to keep pups engaged while providing different textures for chewing and playing. The soft, lightweight materials make them easy for small breeds to carry around and enjoy. These toys also help teething puppies by soothing their gums and preventing destructive chewing. Owners love the value of getting multiple toys in one pack, ensuring their small dogs always have something to play with. If you have a small pup, this set is a great way to keep them entertained.
Best Dog Toy for Seniors: KONG Senior is specially designed for older dogs who still love to chew but need a gentler toy. Made from softer, all-natural rubber, it provides classic KONG durability while being easier on aging teeth and gums. It can be stuffed with treats or peanut butter, encouraging mental stimulation and slow feeding. This toy relieves anxiety and keeps senior dogs entertained without causing strain. Many pet owners appreciate how it perfectly balances durability and comfort for aging pups. The KONG Senior is a top pick if your senior dog needs a fun yet gentle toy.
Best Treat Dispenser Dog Toy: Outward Hound by Nina Ottosson Treat Tumble is a fantastic interactive toy that combines play with rewarding treats. Its rolling design encourages dogs to nudge and push it around, releasing treats as they play. This helps keep dogs mentally and physically engaged while promoting slow feeding. Made from durable, non-toxic materials, it’s built to withstand enthusiastic play without breaking. Dog owners love how it turns snack time into a stimulating activity, preventing boredom and promoting problem-solving. This treat dispenser is a great choice if your dog enjoys interactive toys.
Best Frozen Dog Toy: The Nylabone Freezer Knuckle Bone is perfect for teething puppies or dogs that enjoy frozen treats. It is designed to be frozen and provides soothing relief for sore gums while keeping dogs entertained. The textured surface helps massage gums and clean teeth, promoting better oral health. It’s also great for keeping dogs cool on hot days, offering a refreshing chewing experience. Many owners love how this toy keeps their pups occupied while providing a safe and beneficial chewing outlet. This frozen chew is an excellent option for a cooling, teething-friendly toy.
The Bottom Line
The right toy isn’t just a plaything—it’s a tool for better behavior, stronger bonds, and a happier, healthier dog. Whether it’s a puzzle feeder that sharpens their mind, a chew toy that saves your furniture, or a tug-of-war rope that strengthens your connection, choosing wisely makes all the difference. So, take a moment to rethink your dog’s toy collection. Are they truly engaged? Challenged? Safe? If not, it’s time for an upgrade. A well-chosen toy doesn’t just entertain—it enriches. And your pup deserves nothing less.
Like It? Subscribe & Share!
Sources
Canine Bible uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process and product review methodology to learn more about how we fact-check, test products, and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
Canine Bible authorship represents the unified voice of our entire editorial team and our in-house veterinarians rather than a single author. Each article, blog post, and review published under the Canine Bible name undergoes a rigorous review process, involving all team members to guarantee accuracy and up-to-date in accordance with the latest veterinarian research. This collaborative effort is an integral part of our editorial process and aligns with our four pillars of content creation. This approach ensures our content is backed by expert knowledge and factual information, offering our readers reliable, actionable, and trustworthy content.
